Blog » CAN YOU SUE FACEBOOK IN YOUR HOME COUNTRY?
CAN YOU SUE FACEBOOK IN YOUR HOME COUNTRY?
12 February 2018
This was the basic question in a lawsuit in Austria filed by a private person against the social media giant. In this short article we explain the decision of the European Court which was published these days.
Maximilian Schrems, an Austrian privacy activist sued Facebook Ireland (“Facebook”) in Austria claiming that Facebook has breached dozens of data protection rules in relation with his own and other private persons private Facebook account. The other private persons assigned to Schrems their claims relating to those private accounts.
Facebook who has its registered seat in Ireland disputed the jurisdiction of the Austrian court. Facebook claimed that Mr. Schrems cannot rely on jurisdiction rule which allows consumers to bring claims in their home EU-country against the other party. The reason for that is that on the one hand, Mr. Schrems is using the Facebook for professional activities as he informs the public about his steps against the Facebook. On the other hand, Mr. Schrems has filed a class-action lawsuit and in Facebook’s opinion the favourable jurisdiction rule cannot be applied if one is willing to enforce assigned claims.
Before the Austrian court could jump into the details of the case he had to seek guidance of the European Court. The question was how the jurisdiction rule shall be interpreted that a consumer may bring proceedings against his contractual party in the courts of his home country if the contract was concluded for a purpose outside his profession.
2. Decision of the Court
First, the Court examined whether the fact that Mr. Schrems is informing the public about his lawsuits against the Facebook or advertises his books on the Facebook excludes him from being a consumer. The Court took into account that Mr. Schrems has a private Facebook account and also a Facebook page where the advertising activity is carried out.
The Court established that the mere fact that a private person publishes books and operates websites does not mean that his Facebook account cannot be considered as private and does not deprive him from his consumer status.
Second, the Court examined whether the specific jurisdiction rule can be applied in the case of assigned claims.
It was the view of the Court that the favourable jurisdiction rule was designed for consumer protection reasons. This kind of protection is only justifiable if the consumer is personally participating in the lawsuit. Therefore, the favourable jurisdiction rule cannot be applied in a proceeding brought by a consumer for the purpose of asserting claims assigned by other consumers.
3. Lessons learnt
All in all, as a consumer you can sue Facebook in your home EU-country even if you carried out some kind of professional activity (eg. on a separate Facebook-page) but only if you enforce your claims personally.
CORONAVIRUS: GOVERNMENTAL MEASURES PROTECTING COMMERCIAL LESSEES IN HUNGARY
The worldwide coronavirus epidemic is causing serious problems in the economy as well, businesses in sensitive sectors fear a total loss of income for months. For this reason, the Hungarian Government introduced a ban on termination and rent increase for commercial lease contract in case the lessee operates in specific, sensitive sectors. However, there are several legal uncertainties surrounding the measure, which will be discussed in our brief article.Read more »
HUNGARY: CHOICE OF LAW BY CONDUCT IN LITIGATION? – JUDGMENT OF SUPREME COURT
Can the conduct of the parties during litigation amount to an implied choice-of-law agreement based on the Rome I Regulation? We analyse the fresh judgment of the Hungarian Supreme Court in this article.Read more »
LABOUR LAW CHANGES DURING THE CORONAVIRUS EPIDEMIC – 4 MEANS AVAILABLE FOR HUNGARIAN EMPLOYERS
The coronavirus is already having its unfortunate impacts in the whole world and there is almost no sector which has not been rocked by the effects of the virus. In this rather difficult situation, it is questionable for the employer how to manage their resources and how to protect their employees. The decree of the government effective from 19th March 2020 gives certain tools to the employers which may help them to optimize their operations and to defend their employees. In our short article we summarize these measures.Read more »